Aerator vs tiller is a popular comparison among gardeners new and experienced. You might be astonished to find out that these two have similarities but have different functions.

Aerator vs Tiller

In this complete guide, we’ll look into the factors that set the lawn aerator apart from a tine tiller.

  Spike and plug aerators Front-tine and rear-tine tillers
Usage Encourages more oxygen and nutrients in the ground Turns soil over to get the ground ready for planting
Hole size Small or medium-sized N/A
Ease of use Relatively easy Easier to control; rear-tine tillers require more strength
Applicable size Ideal for most yard spaces or small garden areas Ideal for small areas; rear-tine tillers are better suited to larger yards
Depth 1 to 2.5 inches deep; 1 to 6 inches deep for plug aerators 6 to 8 inches deep; 6 to 12 inches deep for rear-tine tillers

What Are the Differences Between Aerator and Tiller?

The main difference between an aerator and tiller is that an aerator is often used to create holes in compact soils to allow nutrients and oxygen to penetrate the root systems of plants, while the tiller is often utilized to turn and prepare the soil for planting seeds and seedlings.

To go past their basic differences, let’s continue exploring each piece of gardening equipment.

What Is the Aerator Best For?

The aerator is best for digging small holes into the ground as a way for plants to access water, nutrients, and oxygen through their roots. Most of the time, the aerator is employed when the soil has started to become compact, creating a thick, impenetrable layer of soil.

Plants can suffocate from too much clay content, which is often the root cause of compacted soils. This type of soil deprives root systems of essential nutrients and elements. As a gardening tool, the aerator is invaluable for gardeners who have high amounts of clay in their garden soil.

Once the soil becomes aerated, plants tend to grow lusher, greener, and more resistant to most pests and diseases. There are basically two types of aerators: the spike aerator and the plug aerator.

– Spike Aerator

A spike aerator tool uses tines, which are sharp points, to dig holes in the ground. These holes will then act as passageways for nutrients and natural elements to penetrate the soil. The holes are typically shallow, about one to three inches deep. Consequently, spike aerators are often recommended for smaller gardens.

– Plug Aerator

On the other hand, a plug aerator has hollow spikes that take out small portions of the soil. This leaves the ground with deeper holes compared to the spike aerator. The holes that are created tend to be from one to six inches, depending on the model. As a result, plug aerators are far better suited for mid to large gardens.

Aerator Characteristics

– Aerator Models

There are also variations of the aerator. Many aerators come in manual models but there are also a lot of models that are powered by gasoline or electricity. Manual aerators are more affordable but will require more effort. Gas-powered or electric aerator models tend to make the whole activity easier and faster.

Gardeners can also opt to purchase lawn aerator shoes, which are shoes with sharp tines attached to the bottom of the soles. As the gardener walks around, the spikes dig into the soil. You can use this as it is or in conjunction with other types of aerators if you wish.

Lawns are typically aerated from time to time, especially when the soil has become heavily compacted. Many gardeners aerate their lawns annually, but you can aerate your lawn only when necessary.

– When To Use an Aerator

If your grass remains lush, green, and healthy, then you don’t need to aerate your lawn. If you decide to aerate your lawn, then ideally the best time to do so would be in the spring or fall. Just make sure that the ground is not too wet so you won’t end up with clumps of soil all over your aerators and your garden.

However, you should always aerate your soil once your grass seeds start to grow. Aerators will help the grass take in more air and nutrients without uprooting or damaging your lawn. Aerators are great choices if your yard has very few issues and you prefer to use this activity as a way to exercise your body.

What Is the Tiller Best For?

The tiller is best for turning over compact soil with ease. As a result, the loosened soil becomes more conducive to gardening and planting. This is due to the tiller having large and sharp tines that can easily break into dense soil.

The act of tilling helps deliver more nutrients into the ground, preparing the soil for new seeds or grass. Tillers are suited for most yard sizes since they work even in the smallest to the largest garden spaces.

There are two types of tillers: the front-tine tiller and the rear-tine tiller. Their types basically describe how each one looks. The front-tine tiller, as we can infer from its name, has tines in the front, while the rear-tine tiller has tines at the back part.

– Front-tine Tillers

Front-tine tillers have their blades in front of the wheels, which makes them easier to operate and navigate. Operators just have to push down the tiller, lift the tines slightly, and start. They are usually smaller than rear-tine tillers but are quite versatile in their uses, such as removing weeds and adding fertilizers to the soil.

– Rear-tine Tillers

On the other hand, rear-tine tillers require more strength since the blades are behind the wheels. Despite the additional effort, rear-tine tillers dig deeper holes. Since their size can make them a bit tricky to navigate, rear-tine tillers are often used in bigger yards where intricate maneuverability is less required.

Tiller Characteristics

– When To Use a Tiller

Tillers are best used during the spring or fall. To make the best use of your tiller, ensure that the ground is not wet. Wet soil can cause clumps of earth all around your yard.

Seeding your lawn is another activity that requires the use of a tiller. Make sure that your lawn gets overseeded right after tilling. Allow the grass to grow and then you can opt to aerate your lawn if need be.

– Aerator Attachments

Some manufacturers even have an aerator attachment for tiller models. This can make your tiller into an aerator, saving you some resources in the long run. For example, the attachment can make your tiller into an aerator, allowing you more storage space. At the same time, you won’t need to buy an aerator anymore, saving you some money.

You can also look into getting a lawn cultivator, which mixes soil instead of turning it over. Most models are powered by gas or electricity, and some models look very similar to lawn mowers or garden edging tools.

They work the soil by mixing the whole ground to make sure that there are no large clumps that could interfere with the nutrient absorption of your lawn or plants. The rotary cultivator can be a good option although there are mixed reviews due to the aluminum tines, which many homeowners find to be too lightweight for such heavy use.


Choosing between the aerator and the tiller will be easier now that you know their basic differences. The aerator is the perfect tool for introducing more water, air, and nutrients into your soil through small perforations in the ground. While there are two major types of aerators, you can easily look into other variations such as ones that are fashioned into footwear.

Tillers, on the other hand, are better suited for more gardening activities. Aside from turning over the soil to prepare for new seeds and plants, aerator attachments can be added to tillers. This makes tillers more functional and flexible than aerators and can be a better option, especially if your garden area is medium to large.

5/5 - (5 votes)
Evergreen Seeds