Disadvantages of mulching grass are various, and some might even surprise you, hence mulching clippings of grass have been known to require more maintenance from the mower. Spreading organic mulches over the lawn only sometimes leads to a healthy and thriving lawn.

11 Disadvantages of Mulching Grass

This process has been known to occasionally cause undue soil dampness, a messy lawn, and pest infestations. It could also create a mess in the lawn and attract pests to the grass.

Read our complete list of all the major disadvantages you didn’t know came with regular mulching of lawn.

List of Disadvantages of Mulching Grass 

1. Soil Stays Damp Longer

Soil Stays Damp Longer

Mulching with a thick layer can impede water evaporation, keeping the soil excessively damp. While moisture is vital, an overly wet environment can lead to root rot, affecting the grass's health.

Prolonged soil dampness creates a breeding ground for fungal overgrowth and root rot. These issues compromise plant health, hindering growth and vitality. Proper drainage and balanced watering are essential to maintain a thriving garden.

When soil retains excessive moisture due to hot and humid weather, it creates a breeding ground for fungal overgrowth and root rot. Fungi thrive in damp conditions, attacking plant roots and leading to various diseases.

To address soil retaining excessive moisture, opt for a thin, evenly spread layer of mulch. This allows for proper air circulation, preventing fungal issues and root rot. It also conserves moisture without suffocating plants.

When a very thick layer of grass mulch is spread over the soil, this can cause the soil to become and then stay damp for a long time. This rise in humidity, of course, is not much of a good situation and the reason is that damp soil leads to the rotting of grassroots and promotes fungal overgrowth. A constantly damp soil also attracts harmful sap-sucking pests to the lawn. 

On the other hand, this problem with mulch becomes more pertinent during the hot and humid summertime, which is also when the grass would begin to grow and establish at its peak.

Not only does the soil stay damp, but it also becomes more compact, which means that the drainage is affected badly. Moreover, when the soil is compact, it means that it doesn’t have the right aeration subjected to it. 

2. Creating A Messy Situation

Creating A Messy Situation

Mulching grass, especially on windy days, can lead to a messy garden due to grass clippings being scattered around. While mulching is beneficial, consider wind patterns and adjust mulching practices to minimize the mess

A messy environment due to mulching can require additional effort in cleaning the lawn. Clippings clumping together might hinder grass growth. Proper mulching techniques can prevent clumping.

A messy lawn post-mulching can result from wet grass and non-mulching mowers. Wet grass clings, making cleanup challenging. Choosing the right equipment and waiting for dry conditions can help maintain a neater garden effortlessly.

To tackle a messy lawn after mulching, opt for a mulching mower and bag clippings instead. This ensures a cleaner garden, promoting healthier grass growth.

Even though a mulching mower cuts grass clippings into fine little pieces, the result is an extremely messy lawn. No matter how much the mulching mower manufacturer that you have has claims to give you pitch-perfect covering, the reality will be much worse. The mulched clippings will inevitably clump together all over the lawn to create weirdly-shaped mounds. 

The clippings will also get stuck to the lawn mower’s deck, which, in turn, will need more frequent cleaning, and this would be a worrying and an exhausting cause for you. Walking on the lawn will become a big hassle, too, because this protection layer is one that will get stuck all over your boots and shoes, resulting into a cleaning process after the work is done. 

On the other hand, remember that these clippings will get strewn all over the lawn, the patio, and even on the fence and walls on a windy day. In this case, you are opening the door to content lawn care and cleaning when you choose mulch over bagging grass clippings.

3. The Lawn Mower Maintenance Goes Up

The Lawn Mower Maintenance Goes Up

Mulching grass can increase lawn mower maintenance due to quicker blade dulling and higher fuel consumption. Regular blade sharpening and efficient fuel use become essential, ensuring a well-maintained garden.

Mulching grass can lead to increased lawn mower maintenance, demanding more frequent blade sharpening and higher fuel expenses. It’s essential to factor in these costs for a well-kept garden.

Lawn mower maintenance costs rise due to factors like using regular blades instead of non-mulching ones and not operating the mower at its full potential. Choosing the right equipment and techniques is key to efficient and budget-friendly gardening.

To tackle rising lawn mower maintenance costs due to mulching, opt for specialized mulching blades and maintain them diligently. Regular sharpening ensures efficient grass cutting.

Lawn mower blades dull much more quickly when used to make mulch cut grass blades regularly. This goes for mulching and non-mulching blades because mulching takes more effort than simply mowing grass.

However, under usual circumstances, your blades must be sharpened only once per year, preferably before winterizing them in a perfect manner so that they would stay neat. On the other hand, in the case of regular mulching, the blade will have to be mulched about three to four times more than that.

One thing you can do to stop the wearing down of blades is to perform this process only when the grass has been cut low or when only a small portion of the lawn is mowed. When you do so it would also increase the maintenance need of your mower that would otherwise not be a necessary requirement. 

You will have to clean the air filters more often, and the spark plug will need frequent changes. Mulching sounds much less useful when you think about all the work that will eventually go into it.

4. The Soil Might Overheat

The Soil Might Overheat

Soil overheating occurs with mulch exceeding 2-4 inches in thickness, hindering proper aeration. This stifles root growth and can harm plants. Opt for proper mulching depth for a thriving garden!

Overheated soil can harm roots and encourage fungal growth, posing risks to plant health. Maintaining proper mulch depth ensures optimal temperatures, fostering a thriving garden.

In hot, humid weather and rainy days, mulch can trap excess heat, causing soil to overheat. This affects plant roots and promotes fungal growth. Proper mulch management is crucial for a healthy garden in varying weather conditions.

To prevent soil overheating due to mulching, opt for a thin layer, allowing proper aeration. Regularly aerating the soil enhances its health, ensuring your plants thrive without the risk of overheating.

Mulch must be two to four inches thick over your grass. When using an excessively thick layer of this part of the grass, there is a risk of overheating the soil during the long, hot summer days. The moisture locked in the protection and the lack of proper ventilation are responsible for causing this. 

When the soil overheats, then it would cause different problems, and it may even become weaker in its growth. What you should do is aerate it, so that you would be avoiding this manner, because you wouldn’t want it to become weaker gradually.

5. Production of Hydrogen Sulfide

Production of Hydrogen Sulfide

When mulch is overly thick and consists of decaying grass, it can lead to the production of Hydrogen Sulfide. Maintaining a balanced mulch layer is crucial, ensuring healthy decomposition without the risk of harmful gas formation.

The production of Hydrogen Sulfide due to excessive mulching can harm grass and pose a threat to animals. Ensuring proper mulch depth is vital, promoting a safe environment for both your plants and the wildlife sharing your garden space.

Dehydrated grass that easily burns is a significant factor leading to Hydrogen Sulfide production during mulching. Keeping your lawn well-watered ensures healthy, vibrant grass and avoids potential issues.

To prevent your pets from ingesting Hydrogen Sulfide from the grass, a straightforward solution is just keeping your pets away. This ensures a safer environment for both your garden and your furry friends.

One rare but potentially more risky consequence of mulching grass clippings over the lawn is the production of hydrogen sulfide gas. This usually happens when a thick layer, in this case, will spread compactly over the lawn. The thing with hydrogen sulfide is that it is a gas that is toxic for both pets and humans. 

In this case, you must not panic just yet because mulch’s amount of hydrogen peroxide is not enough to produce serious toxicity to you and your pets. However, the risk persists, especially if you have nosy pets sniffing the lawn, as they will create somewhat of a hazard. The real risk posed by hydrogen peroxide is to the grass growing in the lawn because it gets burnt.

6. Fertilization Is a Risk

Fertilization Is a Risk

Mulching grass provides natural nutrients as it decomposes. However, combining it with additional fertilizer can lead to overfertilization, impacting your garden negatively. It's best to strike a balance for optimal plant health.

Overfertilization due to mulching grass can harm your garden. It leads to burned roots and yellowing grass, indicating stress and nutrient imbalance. Finding the right balance ensures a lush, healthy garden.

Overfertilization from mulching grass can occur if chemical fertilizers aren't diluted properly and if fertilizing frequency exceeds the monthly limit. It's crucial to follow guidelines to maintain a healthy garden.

To prevent overfertilization due to mulching, apply fertilizer every four weeks and dilute it to one-third of its concentration. This ensures plants receive nutrients without causing harm.

A couple of problems come with combining chemical fertilizer and mulch simultaneously. First, mulch itself breaks down rapidly to convert into organic fertilizer for the grass.

However, if you pour a commercial fertilizer on top of it, this could lead to over-fertilizing, which is just as bad as under-fertilizing for the grass, which is why you should be mindful about it and abstain from doing so. 

In addition, the second thing you need to worry about is liquid fertilizer burning the grass blades off and turning them yellow, as they would begin to lose their color, and this happens from the layer of extra grass over live grass, the fertilizer will stay there longer.

Even if you use a well-diluted fertilizer, it would still end up burning grass and causing more harm than good.

7. The Mower Needs More Work

The Mower Needs More Work

Mulching grass can strain mowers due to specialized blades requiring extra power and fuel. Regular maintenance and choosing appropriate blades can alleviate this strain, ensuring a healthy lawn and a happy mower.

Overworking mowers with mulching strains engines, leading to quicker wear and increased fuel costs. Optimal maintenance and blade choice ensure a lush lawn without burdening your mower excessively.

Overworking mowers due to mulching can result from using standard blades, straining engines and increasing wear. Opting for mulching-specific blades ensures a healthy lawn and eases the load on your mower.

To avoid mower strain from mulching, manually bag clippings for mulch or purchase pre-made mulch. This lightens the load on your mower, ensuring a healthier lawn.

If you want to use this cover that traps moisture in order to improve the quality of your lawn, then the mowed grass needs to be chopped down very finely. With a non-mulching type of mower, you will need to collect the cut grass pieces and then cut them down yourself till they are the right size. This is too much yard work and effort after growing through grass mowing. 

The reason behind this is that your ordinary mower will have to put in a lot of effort and power, and it still will need to do a better job. To save yourself from all that trouble, you need to save some money and buy a good mulching lawn mower.

This would be the factor that would make sure how the mulch is of the highest quality and in the shortest possible time.

8. Pests Are Attracted To Mulch

Pests Are Attracted To Mulch

Mulching grass can invite pests due to the moisture-rich environment it creates, appealing to insects. Additionally, pests are lured by the nutrient-rich mulch. Proper mulching techniques can minimize this issue.

Attracting pests through mulching grass can lead to infestations, causing the grass to thin and turn yellow. This compromises the garden's health. Vigilance and proper garden maintenance are key to prevent such issues.

Lawns lacking pest treatment and have humid soil conditions are prime factors attracting pests due to mulching. Addressing these aspects ensures a healthier garden environment. Stay vigilant and maintain your garden's well-being

To curb pest issues from mulching, consider removing excess mulch and employing insecticides judiciously. Balancing these steps ensures a pest-free garden, fostering healthy plant growth.

This is among the worst consequences of covering the lawn with mulch grass after mowing. All sorts of pests are attracted to this mulch, which also serves as their hiding ground. 

To narrow it down, this is the case of some sap-sucking pests like spider mites here and larger ones like slugs and snails, which would damage the lawn in the long run. The thing with snails and slugs is that they like to munch on the clippings and live grass blades. These pets will end up destroying an otherwise healthy lawn because they are attracted to the layer of mulch covering it. 

9. Might Spread Weeds

Might Spread Weeds

Weeds in mulch often stem from contained weed seeds, especially in homemade mulch. It's crucial to source mulch carefully to prevent weed infiltration, ensuring a flourishing garden.

Weeds infiltrating your garden due to mulching can lead to undesirable outcomes such as rampant weed growth and thinning of the grass. Vigilance in mulch selection is key to maintaining a lush garden.

Mulching grass with material from a weed-infested lawn introduces weed seeds, causing unwanted growth and spread of these annoying weeds. Opt for weed-free mulch to preserve your garden's beauty.

To combat weed spread due to mulching grass, remove existing weeds diligently. Opt for store-bought mulch and ensure that it's weed-free in order to maintain your garden's health and vibrancy.

Usually, when the grass is used to make mulch, what happens is that this grass is first mow from the lawn and then cut into small mulch-sized pieces. While the type that is produce by the mower will convert cut grass to mulch simultaneously, a regular mower or a weed trimmer will first cut grass, and then you must chop it up manually. 

During this process, you will find naturally ripe weed from the ground, which will get mixed up with the pieces that were cut. When this cover is laid down on the lawn, you will have to deal with an explosive growth of weeds and invasive species that you have contributed to spreading. 

This is such a common and inevitable consequence of mulching that it has caused many people to denounce mulching for the rest of their lives. You can remove weeds from the entire lawn and mow it for mulching. Yes, this is just as tedious in practice as it sounds on hearing.

10. Cause Soil Dryness

Cause Soil Dryness

Using mulch layers that are thicker than four inches can lead to soil dryness. Maintain a balanced mulch thickness for optimal moisture retention, ensuring your garden thrives.

When mulch is too thick, water struggles to penetrate, causing soil dryness. Ensure proper watering techniques to bypass this issue. Let rainwater nourish your garden by moderating mulch depth.

Soil dryness due to mulching is influenced by shallow roots and the absence of underground water sources. Deep-rooted plants and proper irrigation methods can alleviate this concern.

Combat soil dryness with a thin mulch layer and finely cut grass. This promotes water penetration, nurturing plant roots effectively. Incorporate these techniques to create a favorable environment for your plants.

Using grass clippings as mulching has been known to lock moisture in the soil by preventing its evaporation into the air. However, sometimes when a very thick layer is used, it has the exact opposite effect. 

As you have placed this thick layer, now it is one responsible to only absorb any water you provide your lawn, and only a small amount will reach the soil. The lawn patches where the mulch layer is the thickest will start turning yellow and wispy from lack of moisture in the soil.

11. Clogs the Mower

Clogs the Mower

Cutting wet grass while mulching can lead to a clogged mower as the moist grass clippings tend to clump together. This obstructs the mower's blades and hampers its efficiency. It's essential to mow when the grass is dry to prevent this issue.

A clogged mower due to mulching wet grass can cause problems by obstructing the mower deck. Additionally, the damp environment created by the clippings attracts diseases and pests, posing risks to your lawn's health.

Mowing grass after rain or watering increases the likelihood of a clogged mower. Moist grass clippings clump together, hindering the mower's efficiency. Waiting for the grass to dry before mowing reduces clogs.

The key solution to avoid a clogged mower due to mulching grass is to mulch only when the grass is dry. Dry grass is less likely to clump, ensuring a smoother mulching process and a healthier garden.

Another key disadvantage of mulching is that it can only be carried out when the grass and the soil are completely dry. Otherwise, you look at a huge mess and an unbearable amount of lawn care.

This will end up ripping the grass instead of mowing it neatly, and the mulch must also be cut properly. The mulch pieces will clump together on the lawn and within the mower deck.  The clumps of stuck-together wet mulch serve as a breeding ground for fungal infections and pest infestations.

The lawn will have a bad appearance overall and warrant a thorough cleanup. You must use a putty knife to scrape the mulch from the deck and clogged chutes. Only mow grass and mulch it if it is dry and there is no chance of impending rain for the next few days.


Before concluding our guide on the disadvantages of mulching too much, here is a much-needed recap:

  • Mulching too thick can cause the soil to stay damp for a long time, developing fungus and attracting pests.
  • The lawn looks messy and unkempt every time it is mulched, no matter how finely you chop it up.
  • When you convert grass to mulch, there is a risk of spreading weeds and their spores around.

In this informative article, you read all the major negative side effects of mulching in great detail. Mulching is important to get a lush lawn, but be careful not to overdo it.

5/5 - (6 votes)